Sydney Moo Duk Kwan
  • Home
  • About
    • Moo Duk Kwan
    • Soo Bahk Do
  • Classes
  • Location
  • Theory
  • Newsletters

Theory

Why salute the flags?

1/14/2020

1 Comment

 
When, and why, do we salute the flags in the dojang?
​Understanding the history and the reason we salute the flags can help us better appreciate the significance and meaning behind of this solemn gesture.
Picture
Picture
Salute

Definition
  • Verb: to show respect and recognition by assuming a prescribed position
  • Noun: the position (as of the hand) or the entire attitude of a person saluting a superior

Translation
  • Korean: Gukgi baerae (and various other Romanised versions of the hangul)
  • Meaning: Bow towards the flag

The process
  • Upon entering or leaving the dojang, pause by the entrance, face the flags and salute by holding your right hand open and across your chest with your palm facing your heart. Lower you hand to your side and turn towards to the senior person in the room and bow once; then enter or leave the dojang.
  • During the opening and closing ceremonies, we again salute the flags by raising our right hand across the chest. This is performed following the command “gukgi baerae”, which translates as “bow towards the flag”. It is important to understand that the salute should be directed towards your national flag. 


History of the salute 
To the experienced Moo Do In  (martial artist), saluting the flags makes sense, feels natural and is a meaningful gesture to perform at specific times during class. To the beginner however, especially in western societies, saluting the flags may be an awkward experience, especially if they don’t understand the significance and meaning.

Like many aspects of the protocols we follow during class, the salute is heavily influenced by Korean culture. During the South Korean Pledge of Allegiance and ceremonial salute to the national flag, Koreans stand and, with their right hand held over their heart, recite a short passage which affirms their allegiance to their country. This ceremony if often observed at the beginning of official public events, sporting events and school assemblies and graduations(1). 

The practice of saluting the flag stems from the heavy influence of the military over the Korean culture. The salute is believed to have begun during the Japanese occupation of Korea but has evolved over time. In 1949, the format was initially changed, then in 1968 a modernised version was adopted by the national school system(2), while in 1972 a presidential decree required Koreans to recite the pledge at public gathering and at the start of each week during elementary and high school(3). Although the words were again updated in 2007 to reflect societal changes, the pledge often provokes discussion about its relevance in today’s society, with some claiming the practice is outdated and a remnant of the previous military regime(4). While controversial to some, the salute and pledge are also seen as a symbol of the national bond and patriotism which unified the South Korean people after the Korean War(5).

It is not only in Korea where you may see people performing this salute. Throughout much of Latin America, the United States, Italy, Nigeria and the Philippines, the salute is given by civilians during the playing of their national anthem and at other solemn occasions(6). The gesture is also often seen in Australia performed by dignitaries and civilians when attending military ceremonies. 


Significance and meaning
While we may understand where the salute comes from, understanding it’s meaning and significance gives us a deeper connection to the gesture. The martial arts are influenced by military protocol and custom, however most Moo Do In have little interest in pursuing a military career. It is therefore important to find meaning in actions such as the salute in order to make them relevant in our training. 

In 2014, a Polish study concluded that the hand-over-heart gesture signalled sincere intentions from the participants, and was a trigger for increased honest and moral behaviour(7). Specifically, “the emblematic gesture associated with honesty (putting a hand on one’s heart) increased the level of honesty perceived by others, and increased the honesty shown in one’s own behaviour“(8). 

Of interest, the notion of placing your hand over your heart while making a solemn oath can even be found in a letter dated 8 May 1826 from Mr Laurence Halloran to the (now defunct) Sydney Gazette(9). This demonstrates that the hand-over-heart gesture is not a new phenomenon, and has a history which extends outside Korea.

There are different ideas about how we can apply honesty in our training. By saluting the Australian flag – Australia's foremost national symbol – we are proclaiming to a higher entity than ourselves of our intentions to act in the highest moral and honest manner. This helps us create a positive frame of mind for our training to follow.

Moo Do is an action philosophy; we don’t just talk about our philosophy, we put it into action. By saluting the flags with our hand over the heart, we perform an action that directly connects us to the fourth of the 8 Key Concepts; Chung Jik (honesty). By performing a meaningful and respectful salute, we not only demonstrate our personal Chung Jik, we also connect with two of the 5 Moo Do Values of Iyok Sa (history) and Jon Tong (tradition). 



References
  1. Suk, Gee-hyun (2014) ‘[Uniquely Korean] Pledging allegiance and saluting the flag’, Korea Herald, 19 March. Available at http://www.koreaherald.com/view.php?ud=20140319001020
  2. Ibid.
  3. Moon, Gwang-lip (2007) ‘Pledge of allegiance is revised yet still resisted’, Korea Joong-Ang Daily, 9 July. Available at http://koreajoongangdaily.joins.com/news/article/article.aspx?aid=2877789
  4. Ibid.
  5. Suk, Gee-hyun (2014) ‘[Uniquely Korean] Pledging allegiance and saluting the flag’, Korea Herald, 19 March. Available at http://www.koreaherald.com/view.php?ud=20140319001020
  6. Smithsonian Magazine
  7. Parzuchowski M. and Wojciszke B. (2014) ‘Hand over Heart Primes Moral Judgments and Behavior’, Journal of Nonverbal Behaviour, 2014; 38(1) pp 145-165. Available at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3904064/?report=classic 
  8. Ibid.
  9. Sydney Gazette. Available at https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/2185809?searchTerm=%22hand+on+your+heart%22
​
Additional references
  • Jacobs T. (2017) ‘Placing hand over heart promotes honesty’, Pacific Standard, 14 June. Available at https://psmag.com/social-justice/placing-hand-heart-promotes-honesty-77223
  • Australian National Flag website, Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet. Available at https://www.pmc.gov.au/government/australian-national-flag

1 Comment
Elodie Mollet link
1/14/2020 10:01:28 pm

Thank you for this article, Sydney Moo Duk Kwan.
Some years ago, we decided in Paris to use only the Moo Duk Kwan flag.
There were many reasons of that :
- we had many training places and only 1 flag at the beginning and we had to hang it up each class.
- our founder Sa Bom in France has been a Korean, and use to teach many foreigners in his class in Paris. So the Moo Duk Kwan flag was the reason why we gathered training as many nationalities were represented.
- we do not have the culture in France to bow the flag, except in military or for international sport events. As Soo Bahk do is non of the 2, using the France flag looks not only unnatural but not accurate to what we've been doing in do-jangs.
- if our goal is to honor Mission 2000 and the creation of a worldwide practice, should not we promote an international citizenship ? If we want to increase an awareness of common future on our planet Earth, should not we use as less as possible our local flag ?
Respectfully
E.M

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    February 2021
    January 2020
    August 2019
    April 2018
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017

    Categories

    All
    Philosophy
    Technique

    AUTHOR

    Kim Wyles, instructor at Sydney Moo Duk Kwan

© 2021 Sydney Moo Duk Kwan.  Est 2014.
Made with Moo Do
  • Home
  • About
    • Moo Duk Kwan
    • Soo Bahk Do
  • Classes
  • Location
  • Theory
  • Newsletters